What is a Closed Access city?

In my review of the housing boom and bust, I have gradually come to a categorization of major American cities which explains their broad differences.

Among the top 20 cities:

Closed Access cities: New York City, Los Angeles, Boston, San Francisco (and San Jose), and San Diego

These cities all share various peculiar and related characteristics.  High and rising incomes, very low rates of homebuilding, rising rents, rising home prices, and a turnstile migration pattern of high income households moving in and low income households moving out.  These have become enclaves of privilege for high earning workers where both (1) workers and firms that would compete with them are obstructed by high cost of living, and (2) service workers who would have followed those high earning workers into the cities so that they could also capture some of the gains of new economic growth are locked out of that opportunity for lack of homes.  This has created a sort of meritocratic elitist economy.  This is the core challenge of our time.


Contagion cities: Miami, Phoenix, Riverside (CA), and Tampa (essentially inland California, Arizona, Nevada, and Florida)

During the housing boom, there was tremendous out-migration of residents out of the Closed Access cities, because of the lack of housing.  Millions of households have moved out of those cities over the past 20 years.  The Contagion areas are the areas that take in most of that migration.  When this problem peaked in 2004-2006, these cities were overwhelmed with new residents and with former Closed Access homeowners who were reinvesting in Contagion city homes that were much less expensive than their previous homes.  In these cities, we might call what happened a bubble, but what happened there was really the opposite of what was happening in the Closed Access cities.  The price spike in these cities tended to be sharper, for a shorter amount of time, and at much lower price points, than the Closed Access cities.  And, it was tied to very high levels of in-migration of new tenants putting pressure on the local housing stock - both owners and renters.


Open Access cities: Atlanta, Houston, and Dallas (most smaller metro areas also fit this type)

These cities had generous rates of new homebuilding, like Phoenix, Tampa, etc., but they were removed enough from Closed Access cities that they never saw as large a spike in in-migration as the Contagion cities did, so they didn't develop the temporary bubble markets that the Contagion cities did.  Real long term interest rates were low during the boom, which did create moderate price increases in these cities, but prices never moved out of historical norms.


These aren't perfect categories.  Cities like Seattle and Washington, DC have some Closed Access characteristics.  Incomes there are high and housing costs are relatively high.  But, those cities don't have the turnstile migration pattern of the Closed Access cities, because, in spite of some pressures that limit homebuilding, they still manage to build a reasonable number of new units.  Rent inflation in these cities has been generally high, like in the Closed Access cities, but rents have not become so high that households in low tier markets have been forced out of the city by affordability problems.  They can adjust their unit size, location, and amenities within the city.  Maybe this means that Seattle and Washington, DC are infant Closed Access cities, and it's more a matter of degrees than of kind, and when rent inflation eventually causes rents to rise high enough, migration will ensue.  But, the fact of the matter is they really do allow more homes to be built than the Closed Access cities, so the difference between these cities and Closed Access cities will be an interesting topic to follow over time.

7 comments:

  1. Thank you for this great post and amazing tips. Very helpful info

    Travel
    Tourism
    Vacation
    Hotels
    Best Vacation Spots

    ReplyDelete
  2. Total Nonsense. YOUR IMPLYING THAT REAL ESTATE MARKETS ARE HETEROGENOUS. THEY ARE NOT. WHAT HAPPENS IN LAS VEGAS HAPPENS EVERYWHERE.

    ReplyDelete
  3. QUICK LOAN OFFER BUSINESS AND PERSONAL LOAN


    Fast cash loan offer for you today at just 2% interest rate, both long and short term cash of all amounts and
    currencies, no collateral required. We offer loans from a minimum range of $2000 to a maximum of $20 million.We
    are certified and your privacy is 100% safe with us Apply now for your instant approval and transfer approval process takes just 3

    hours. contact us now I'll advise you can contact us via email at
    abdullahibrahimlender@gmail.com
    Whatspp +917738214856
    Mr Abdullah

    ReplyDelete

  4. Good day: you need an urgent loan to solve your financial needs, we
    offer a range from $ 5,000.00 to $ 10,000,000.00 loan Max, we are
    reliable, efficient, fast and dynamic, with a 100% guaranteed and we
    also gives credit to (. euros, pounds and dollars) the interest rate
    applicable to all payday loans (2%), if you are interested get back to
    us through with the information below: full
    name: Country: Amount of the loan Address: Duration: Age: Gender:
    Occupation: phone number: Thanks. I await your urgent response
    Whats app +918130061433.

    ReplyDelete

  5. Do you need a financial help? Are you in any financial crisis or do you need funds to start up your own business? Do you need funds to settle your debt or pay off your bills or start a good business? Do you have a low credit score and you are finding it hard to obtain capital services from local banks and other financial institutes? Here is your chance to obtain a financial services from our company. We offer the following finance to individuals-
    *Commercial finance
    *Personal finance
    *Business finance
    *Construction finance
    *Business finance And many More:
    and many more at 2% interest rate;
    Contact Us Via Email:bullsindia187@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. I can’t believe this is really true I never believe there is cure to this hsv 2 because all the hospital have told me there is no cure to it, few months ago I saw this man email DR.kuta on internet from a testimony share by someone who he help with his herbal cure I contact his email and ask for his help also, that is how he inform me about the cure process and this man sent me a herbal medicine which I took according to the way he instructed for 2 week I can’t believe when I go for test my result come out negative i am so happy to share this to the world there is real cure to herpes you can also contact DR.kuta through his email now drkutaherbalcenter@gmail.com and also WhatsApp him +2347054547814 and He also have herbs medicine to cured the following diseases;
    Diabetes, Lupus, HPV, Gout, Hepatitis A,B, Infertility, HIV/AIDS, CANCER

    ReplyDelete
  7. What are your Financial needs? We give out loans from a minimum of $7,000 to a maximum of $900,000,000.00 with comfortable duration that ranges from 1 to 25 years at a very reduced interest rate of 3%. Contact us via email: mrfrankpoterloanoffer@gmail.com
    Thanks and look forward to your prompt reply.
    Regards,

    ReplyDelete