What is a Closed Access city?

In my review of the housing boom and bust, I have gradually come to a categorization of major American cities which explains their broad differences.

Among the top 20 cities:

Closed Access cities: New York City, Los Angeles, Boston, San Francisco (and San Jose), and San Diego

These cities all share various peculiar and related characteristics.  High and rising incomes, very low rates of homebuilding, rising rents, rising home prices, and a turnstile migration pattern of high income households moving in and low income households moving out.  These have become enclaves of privilege for high earning workers where both (1) workers and firms that would compete with them are obstructed by high cost of living, and (2) service workers who would have followed those high earning workers into the cities so that they could also capture some of the gains of new economic growth are locked out of that opportunity for lack of homes.  This has created a sort of meritocratic elitist economy.  This is the core challenge of our time.

Contagion cities: Miami, Phoenix, Riverside (CA), and Tampa (essentially inland California, Arizona, Nevada, and Florida)

During the housing boom, there was tremendous out-migration of residents out of the Closed Access cities, because of the lack of housing.  Millions of households have moved out of those cities over the past 20 years.  The Contagion areas are the areas that take in most of that migration.  When this problem peaked in 2004-2006, these cities were overwhelmed with new residents and with former Closed Access homeowners who were reinvesting in Contagion city homes that were much less expensive than their previous homes.  In these cities, we might call what happened a bubble, but what happened there was really the opposite of what was happening in the Closed Access cities.  The price spike in these cities tended to be sharper, for a shorter amount of time, and at much lower price points, than the Closed Access cities.  And, it was tied to very high levels of in-migration of new tenants putting pressure on the local housing stock - both owners and renters.

Open Access cities: Atlanta, Houston, and Dallas (most smaller metro areas also fit this type)

These cities had generous rates of new homebuilding, like Phoenix, Tampa, etc., but they were removed enough from Closed Access cities that they never saw as large a spike in in-migration as the Contagion cities did, so they didn't develop the temporary bubble markets that the Contagion cities did.  Real long term interest rates were low during the boom, which did create moderate price increases in these cities, but prices never moved out of historical norms.

These aren't perfect categories.  Cities like Seattle and Washington, DC have some Closed Access characteristics.  Incomes there are high and housing costs are relatively high.  But, those cities don't have the turnstile migration pattern of the Closed Access cities, because, in spite of some pressures that limit homebuilding, they still manage to build a reasonable number of new units.  Rent inflation in these cities has been generally high, like in the Closed Access cities, but rents have not become so high that households in low tier markets have been forced out of the city by affordability problems.  They can adjust their unit size, location, and amenities within the city.  Maybe this means that Seattle and Washington, DC are infant Closed Access cities, and it's more a matter of degrees than of kind, and when rent inflation eventually causes rents to rise high enough, migration will ensue.  But, the fact of the matter is they really do allow more homes to be built than the Closed Access cities, so the difference between these cities and Closed Access cities will be an interesting topic to follow over time.


  1. Replies

    1. Fast, Free Personal Loan Offers in Minutes. Compare Loans & Find Your Best Offer! One Simple Form Gets You Up to Five Personalized Loan Offers in Minutes. Start Now!
      Auto Loans, Personal Loans, Mortgage, RefinanceCredit, CardsStudent Loans and business start up .
      contact us
      E-mail__ Atlasloan83@gmail . com
      Phone/Whatsapp__ + 1 443 345 9339



    Fast cash loan offer for you today at just 2% interest rate, both long and short term cash of all amounts and
    currencies, no collateral required. We offer loans from a minimum range of $2000 to a maximum of $20 million.We
    are certified and your privacy is 100% safe with us Apply now for your instant approval and transfer approval process takes just 3

    hours. contact us now I'll advise you can contact us via email at
    Whatspp +917738214856
    Mr Abdullah


  4. Good day: you need an urgent loan to solve your financial needs, we
    offer a range from $ 5,000.00 to $ 10,000,000.00 loan Max, we are
    reliable, efficient, fast and dynamic, with a 100% guaranteed and we
    also gives credit to (. euros, pounds and dollars) the interest rate
    applicable to all payday loans (2%), if you are interested get back to
    us through with the information below: full
    name: Country: Amount of the loan Address: Duration: Age: Gender:
    Occupation: phone number: Thanks. I await your urgent response
    Whats app +918130061433.


  5. Do you need a financial help? Are you in any financial crisis or do you need funds to start up your own business? Do you need funds to settle your debt or pay off your bills or start a good business? Do you have a low credit score and you are finding it hard to obtain capital services from local banks and other financial institutes? Here is your chance to obtain a financial services from our company. We offer the following finance to individuals-
    *Commercial finance
    *Personal finance
    *Business finance
    *Construction finance
    *Business finance And many More:
    and many more at 2% interest rate;
    Contact Us Via Email:bullsindia187@gmail.com


  6. In light of genuine occasions and the novel composed by Paulo Lins, The film centers around the ascent of sorted out 123movies wrongdoing in Rio de Janeiro and one of the street pharmacists directly in center of it named Li'l Zé in the late 60′s and right into the mid 80′s.

  7. You have performed a great job on this article. It’s very precise and highly qualitative. You have even managed to make it readable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you so much Commercial Finance Specialists Australia

  8. Get the best seo services in India from seo company India. Quality of work is guaranteed here. We also offer other marketing services to drive traffic and boost conversions.

  9. I Want To Appreciate Dr OLIHA for his great deeds, I Was Diagnosed With type 2 Herpes Virus Last year, And I Was Looking For Solution To Be Cured Luckily I Saw Testimonies On How Dr OLIHA Cure Herpes Virus I Decided To Contact Dr OLIHA I Contacted Him He Prepared A Herbal Medicine Portion And Sent It To Me, I Started The Herbal Medicine For My Health. He Gave Me Step By Step Instructions On How To Apply It, When I Applied It As Instructed, I Was Cured Of This Deadly Herpes Within 2 weeks, I Am Now Herpes Negative. My Brother And Sister I No That There Are So Many People That Have The Same Herpes Virus Please contact Dr OLIHA To Help You Too, And Help Me To Thank Dr OLIHA For Cure Me, I’m Cured By Dr. OLIHA Herbal Medicine, His Contact Email:{oliha.miraclemedicine@gmail.com} or visit his website is https://olihamiraclemedicine.webs.com/  or  Cell Whatsapp Number +2349038382931 thank you

  10. I'm 40 years old female I tested genital herpes (HSV1-2) positive in 2016. I was having bad outbreaks. EXTREMELY PAINFUL. I have try different kinds of drugs and treatment by the medical doctors all to know was avail. Six months ago I was desperately online searching for a helpful remedies for genital herpes (HSV1-2) cure, which I come across some helpful remedies on how Dr OYAGU have help so many people in curing genital herpes (HSV1-2) with the help of herbal treatment because I too believe there is someone somewhere in the world who can cure herpes completely. At of the past 2 months, however, I've been following his herpes protocol Via oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or +2348101755322 and it stopped all outbreaks completely! To my greatest surprise I was cured completely by following the protocol of his herbal medicine . Don't be discouraged by the medical doctors. There is a cure for HSV with the help of herbs and roots by a herbalist Dr call Dr OYAGU he is so kind and truthful with his herbal treatment, kindly contact him for more information Via oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or WhatsApp DR on +2348101755322 or visit his website https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome you will be lucky as I am today

  11. Never give up in life they all say no cure to HSV 2 which is a big lie I have pass through many process also i never believe there is really cure to HERPES until I meet Dr.odoma the doctor that have been helping many people for many years, I come across this doctor online when I was searching for cure online I found out about this man, and to my greatest surprise this man have the herbal medicine which I have been looking for years I explain my problem to him through the email I found on someone who testify about him also, Dr.odoma write me a reply and explain how the process work so after ordering for the medicine I got it within 4 days and I took it according to the way Dr.odoma instructed, I was so happy after two week I took the medicine there was very big change in my health when I was done with the process I go for test, I found out I am negative that was the day I have the tears of joy you can also get in contact with my doctor through his website: https://drodomasolutionhome.simdif.com/ or email now drodomasolutionhome20@gmail.com, you can also WhatsApp him +2348100649947. And He also have herbs medicine to cured the following diseases; eczema,urethra wart,chronic problems.Herpes, Cancer, Als,Hepatitis, Diabetes, HPV,Infections,ulcer ETC

  12. I also thank God that I find a true doctor who cure me from herpes

    I was diagnosed of HERPES Virus in 2013 and I have tried all I can to get cured but all to no avail, until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbalist man who prepare herbal medication to cure all kind of diseases including HERPES virus, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try , when i contact this herbalist via his email and he prepared a HERPES herbal cure and sent it to me via UPS delivery company service, when i received this herbal cure, he gave me step by directions on how to apply it, when i applied it as instructed, i was totally cured of this deadly disease within 14days of usage, I am now free from the deadly disease called herpes, all thanks to Dr ODOMA you can rich this great herbal doctor via his email: (drodomasolutionhome20@gmail.com) call or whatsapp him on his mobile number +2348100649947.
    He also have the herb to cure:
    (1) ALS,
    (2) DIABETES,
    (3) HIV AIDS,
    (5) CANCER,
    (6) HERPES
    (7) HPV
    You can also visit his website:

  13. DR OYAGU herbal medicine is a good remedy for herpes simplex virus cure. My name is MIGNON WRIGHT , am from USA,I am here to give my testimony about DR OYAGU who helped me in my life, i want to inform the public how i was cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) by DR OYAGU, i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like Familiar, Zovirax, and Valtrex which is very expensive to treat the symptoms and never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HERPES and i saw comment of people talking about how DR OYAGU cured them, when i contacted him he gave me hope and send a Herbal medicine to me that i took and it seriously worked for me, am a free person now without any problem, my HERPES result came out negative, I pray to God to never let me and my family forget you in our life, am now cured permanently, you can also get your self cured my friends if you really need this doctor help, you can reach him on his website ;https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome Email: oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or via whatsapp +2348101755322

  14. It's a pleasure for me to write this testimony about how I got my Genital Herpes cured a month ago. I have been reading so many comments of some people who were cured from various diseases by Dr. Oliha, but I never believed them. I was hurt and depressed, I was too curious and wanted to try Dr.Oliha, then I contacted him through his email ( oliha.miraclemedicine@gmail.com ) when I contacted him, he assured me 100% that he will heal me, i pleaded with him to help me out. My treatment was a great success, he healed me just as he promised. He sent me his medication and asked me to go for a check up after 14 days of taking the medication. I agreed with him and I took his medication and went for a check up, to my greatest surprise my result was negative after the treatment, i am really happy that I am cured and healthy again. I have waited for 3weeks to be very sure I was completely healed before writing this testimony. I did another blood test one week ago and it was still Herpes negative. So I guess it's time I recommend that anyone going through Herpes HSV-1 or HSV-2, HIV, HPV, Hepatitis B, Diabetes, Cancer should reach him through his Email oliha.miraclemedicine@gmail.com OR add him on whatsapp +2349038382931.
    visit his website on https://olihamiraclemedicine.webs.com/ .

  15. We will advise you to repair the problems that are denying you from performing AOL mail login. Though it is quite easy to log into AOL Mail. But sometimes the issues occur due to the settings of your browser or your network. For assistance, contact our technicians or check our website. AOL com login

  16. We would always love to guide you with your Arlo camera setups. So, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us if you need any help with your Arlo Setup. Installation to log in; you can find all the instructions about the configurations of your Arlo with us. So, please prefer to get in touch with us if you want to find the best guidance for you.

  17. Want to know about the RR Email Login? Then don't worry. We want to assure you that logging into your Roadrunner email account is not difficult at all. You can just visit our website to know all about it. Here, we can help you with troubleshooting the login issues and login into your account successfully. So, please consider reaching out to our Roadrunner help page to know all about it.

  18. We'd be very happy to guide you with your Brighthouse Email account. To understand the features and configurations of your email account with us, visit our website. We can help you to log in, configure and troubleshoot your account without any trouble. So, please consider visiting our website to know all of the information about your email account.

  19. We would love to guide you with your Linksys Velop Setup. The router setup is easy to install and configure, but you will need some guidance to complete the job. So, to have the most accurate and authentic information, visit our help page. We can also help you log in to your router successfully and fix the issues with your router setup.

  20. We can assist you with your Linksys router setup. So, if you need any help with logging in to your router, come to our website. We are here to help you with Linksys Router Login and also with the issues with the login. Along with this, you can also check for the installation and settings of the router.

  21. We have been providing the necessary assistance for the TWC Email Login. Know how you can access your Twc account from a browser and email client. Also, check how you can add your email account to an email client with the correct server settings to avoid issues with the email login. So, consider us as your helping hand and visit our website to know everything about the login.

  22. We provide general and technical assistance with media streaming devices, Google Chromecast setup. So, to learn about the Chromecast installation, its installation process on a device, its troubleshooting, its settings, how it works, what it is supposed to do, then please visit our website. We can assure you that you won't be disappointed because we believe in the precise information.

  23. Herpes is a serious and recurring disease which can't be cured through drugs or injections by the American doctors but the best way to deal with Herpes is by taking natural herbs medicine for it, I have read about DR odoma the great herbalist doctor who cure me from herpes with his powerful herbal medicine. i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry that he will help me with the natural herbs from God!after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and he sent it to me via UPS SPEED POST and it got to me after 3 days!i used the medicine as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was cured!it's really like a dream but i am so happy! for the people suffering from the following diseases, Cancer, hypothyroidism, Herpes, COPD, HIV, Arthritis, Hpv, Infections,Liver Disease, Autoimmune Diseases, Parkinson's disease,Lupus Canker sore and more should contact him for his herbal medicine because i am a living testimony and i was cured of herpes and his medicine is legit. I sent him what he requested and he sent me his medicine which I took for 3 good weeks and today I am out here with negative results. When I went for the test I was so happy after going through his medication. you can reach him through his email drodomasolutionhome20@gmail.com or call whatsapp number:+2348100649947 he will help you out.....visit his website:
    (facebook page https://www.facebook.com/Drodomaherbalmedicine/

  24. Do you have an Arlo Wireless Doorbell at your home? And you need help with it? Then visit our website. We will help you to know all the Arlo's Wireless and video Doorbells. We can guide you to install the doorbell, set the power kit, and use the bypass mode. So, please give us a chance by visiting us.

  25. We can enable you to be the master of your Arlo Pro 2 camera. For any queries related to your Arlo camera, you can get in touch with us. We will help you get through everything related to your Arlo camera setup,

  26. As I called attention to before, Rocket is fundamentally the storyteller of the film and has followed something else altogether in life contrasted with the other two. https://www.buyyoutubesubscribers.in/

  27. Arlo doorbell installation
    We're here to assist you with the Arlo doorbell installation. You need not worry if it is something new to you. We'll help you. Whether it's a video or wired doorbell, with our guidance, you can install it effortlessly. Besides this, you can also learn about the power kit and bypass mode configurations for your Arlo doorbell. So, consider visiting our website to know all about it.

  28. I want to always read your blogs. I love them. Are you also searching for philosophy of nursing? we are the best solution for you. We are best known for delivering the best

  29. I always prefers to read your article, when i was free from my routine work. these day i was researching on video software. and i look a lot of softwares, and get two best in my point of view.corel videostudio vs wondershare filmora both help to create high quality video content.

  30. i was looking for a tool which manage my paper work during when i reading your blog, i get a Kofax Coupon Code. i am confuse should i purchase it or not,because it not provide a trial version.

  31. One of my friend asked me Is Clip Studio Paint good for 2d and 3d animation design,when i read your blog on internet. i don't know much more about tools and technology, i scrool your lots of article i did't get any information about it.

  32. Your Content is amazing and I am glad to read them. If you are familiar with SEO, you already know how important Links Building. If a link relation is given as dofollow, then you will get a good boost over SERP and Boost your Ranking Buy Services From it 24/7
    dofollow SEO article submission backlinks
    top rated classified website Ads
    forum posting backlinks
    Business listing and local listing
    USA dofollow guest post


  33. Your Content is amazing and I am glad to read them. Thanks for sharing the Blog.this blog is very helpful information for every one.

    solicitud de empleo para llenar

  34. Hii,
    This is great and awesome post for me. i loved to read your blog. it's really-really amazing. thanks for inspired me by your blog.Buy YouTube Subscriber

  35. Do you need to make some changes to a pdf file but don't have the time or money to go out and buy a software program? Don't worry, there is a solution for you! You can now edit pdf files online using a variety of different websites. In this blog post, we will discuss the pros and cons of using online pdf editors, as well as provide you with a list of our favorite sites. So whether you need to make simple changes or do some major editing, there is an online editor out there that can meet your needs!

    Edit pdf online